Final Show of the 2026 Season is coming down the Track!

All aboard for mystery, suspense, laughs, and unexpected turns as Putnam County Playhouse presents Agatha Christie’s Murder on the Orient Express, adapted for the stage by Ken Ludwig. 

Performances will be held September 10–12 and September 16–19. Audiences are invited to board the luxurious Orient Express for seven evenings of intrigue as the train becomes trapped in snow and a passenger is discovered dead. With the murderer still aboard, world-famous Belgian detective Hercule Poirot must sort through a train full of secrets, motives, and suspects to uncover the truth before it is too late.

Ric McFadden stars as the meticulous and brilliant Hercule Poirot. He is joined by Sam Draper as Monsieur Bouc, Debby Lambert as Mary Debenham, Lee Reberger as Hector MacQueen, John Tischer as Michel the Conductor/Head Waiter, Karen Temple as Princess Dragomiroff, Grace Buehler as Greta Ohlsson, Amanda Horcher as Countess Andrenyi, Shelly Green McFadden as Helen Hubbard, and Cameron Wunderlich as Colonel Arbuthnot/Samuel Ratchett.

The cast also includes Liza Tischer as Little Girl, Ashton Kirton as Mother, Brandon Wunderlich as Father, Ella Tischer as The Nanny, Randy Funk as The Man, and Pippin Buehler-Bond as the show mascot.

Directed by Dustin Bond, the production team includes Vickie Parker as assistant director; Shelby Merrill as sound operator; Jennifer Wunderlich as light board operator; Kiersten Lane as costumer; Brandon Wunderlich as stage manager and Ashton Kirton as assistant stage manager; Rose Cash, Randy Funk, Lydia Grove, and Savannah Wolfe as stage crew; Dustin Bond as set designer; and Hannah Lafever as artistic designer.

For 65 years, Putnam County Playhouse has brought live theater, music, laughter, and memorable stories to the local community. Through the work of dedicated volunteers—both onstage and behind the scenes—the Playhouse creates opportunities for local performers, technicians, artists, and audiences to come together and share the experience of live theater. The organization is proud to close its 2026 season with a production that offers both the elegance of a bygone era and the irresistible suspense of one of theater’s best-known mysteries.

Tickets for Murder on the Orient Express are $15 each and may be purchased by visiting or calling the Putnam County Playhouse Box Office. The Box Office will be open Monday through Saturday from 5 to 7 p.m. during both weeks of the production.

Join Putnam County Playhouse this September for a thrilling final trip of the 2026 season—where everyone is a suspect, every clue matters, and the journey is anything but ordinary

My Fair Lady Opens on Putnam County Playhouse Stage


Putnam County Playhouse will present the beloved musical My Fair Lady, opening Thursday, August 13


Based on George Bernard Shaw’s Pygmalion, My Fair Lady follows Eliza Doolittle, a Cockney flower girl whose life changes when Professor Henry Higgins takes on the challenge of transforming her speech and manners. With memorable music, lively choreography, and a story filled with humor and heart, the production explores identity, class, independence, and the question of who has the right to define a person’s future. Tickets are $15 each. The box office will open Monday, August 10, from 5–7 p.m. and will also be open each night during the performance weeks.


Playhouse newcomer, Janani Sridhar stars as Eliza Doolittle, with David Johnson as Professor Henry Higgins and T.J. Tincher as Colonel Pickering. Andrea Young portrays Mrs. Eyensford-Hill, while Alan Skillern plays Freddy Eyensford-Hill and John Mark Day appears as Alfred P. Doolittle. Lee Ann Arnold takes on the role of Mrs. Higgins, and Courtney Slough portrays Mrs. Pearce. Karen Temple plays Mrs. Hopkins. The supporting cast includes John Reach, Dorian Dowd, Jim Elliott, and Kerry Arnold. Miles Jernagan, Emily Gray, Adalyn Ludlow, Gwen Skillern, and Hallie Rice portray various staff and Ensemble members. Noah D. Pettit plays Lord Boxington, with Rose Cash as Lady Boxington. Raylee O’Connor & Logan Kuhne are Featured Dancers in a ballet portion of the show. Jace Flater, Jennifer Wunderlich, Trenton Bright, Kaylie Rohrbaugh, Mikey Henry, Max Bailey, Suzanne Funk, Samantha Funk, Julian Dowd, Willow Scott, and Suzanne Hassler round out the cast as Ensemble members. Bringing the production to the stage is director Kathi Elliott, assisted by Fawn Helmer. Kathryn Dory serves as vocal music director, with Debi Prather as rehearsal pianist, with Eleanor Howard serving as dialect coach.

Ben South manages sound, Shelby Merrill operates the light board, and Bart Jones and Matt Ludlow handle the spotlights. Choreography is created by Josie Cox, Raylee O’Connor, Catherine Ryan-Shager, and Sarah Vawter. The production’s costumes are provided by Shelly Green McFadden and Diana Van Middlesworth, with Pat Armitage designing and constructing 2 new costumes for Eliza. The hair and makeup crew includes Syrci Abbott, Emily Gray, Raylee O’Connor, Brooklynne Smith, and Sarah Vawter.


The set is designed by Matt Helmer, Fawn Helmer, and Linda Gjesvold. Jack Randall Earles provides the pre-show and intermission music. Matt also serves as stage manager, supported by stage crew members Hollis Barcus, Randy Funk, Fawn Helmer, Parker Helmer, and Ashton Kirton. John Reach is the props master. The production orchestra features Debi Prather on piano, Kathryn Dory on keyboards and as conductor, Michelle Newland on horn, and DeDee Schwomeyer on percussion. Audiences are invited to experience the magic, music, and transformation of My Fair Lady beginning August 13. With performances limited to eight evenings, early ticket reservations are encouraged.


Performance Dates: August 13, 14, 15, 19, 20, 21, and 22
Curtain: 8 p.m. nightly
Tickets: $15


Box Office Opening: Monday, August 10, 5–7 p.m.; open each performance night during the run. Tickets may be purchased by stopping by or calling the Playhouse Box Office, during those hours, at 765-653-5880.

Putnam County Playhouse’s “Shakespeared!” Youth Theatre Workshop Article

The Putnam County Playhouse “Shakespeared!” Youth Theatre Workshop is well underway working on two version of The Taming of the Shrew. Performances are open to the public on Friday, July 31st and August 1st at 7pm at the Putnam County Playhouse. Admission is $3 for adults, 12 and under are free.


The middle school group, directed by Eleanor Howard with John Reach assisting, are rehearsing their fun, farcical, and festive comedic version of the play set in the old Italian city of Padua. Miranda Brown, Samantha Funk, and Savannah Wolfe are designing costumes and gathering props, and Nicolette Blackledge will be coordinating the sound design. Directing the high school group in their 1960’s sassy version are David Johnson and Ellen Blackledge with Catherine Ryan-Shager as stage manager, Miranda Brown and Josie Tischer designing and coordinating costumes, Ella Tischer on props, and Nicolette Blackledge coordinating sound. Our Middle School cast includes Hadley Roderick as the title character, Kate, Avalyn Templeton as Petruchio, and rounding out the ensemble are Hollis Barcus, Anna Emmerich, Nola Foy, Lucas Gardner, Zoey Hagerott, Betsy Hatfield, Lenora Hazzard, Charlotte Jones, Millie Jones, Chloe Lane, Ella Marmulewicz, Elijah Neeley, Amber Pennington, Carson Squires, Clark Squires, Cece Wells, Molly West, Kya Williams, Aliana Wilson, and Tatum Wilson.


Our High School cast includes Josie Cox as Kate, Mikey Henry as Petruchio, and completing this talented ensemble are Rose Wood, Jacob Deakins, Alex Gurnon, Evelyn Ryan-Shager, Jeffrey Crabb, Gabriela Briceno, Savannah Wolfe, Mariah Hall, Syrci Abbott, Nicolette Blackledge, Breanna Huchel, Kendra Arruda, Demi Ontrop, Jewelee Butcher, Joeie Johnson, Alex Grayson, Iris Beck, Ashelyn Nugent, and Brooklyn Payne. Created by Caroline Good, the “Shakespeared!” Youth Theatre Workshop program is tailored to provide young players with an opportunity to engage with Shakespeare’s text in a fun way and to see the potential interpretations that lie within the text. Directors of each group devise their own unique versions of the play, all with creative input from their casts. Kids learn about acting, using their imaginations and voices, staging and movement, and that Shakespeare isn’t really scary at all.

Murder on the Orient Express Auditions Coming Around the Bend!

The Putnam County Playhouse invites community members to audition for its upcoming production of Murder on the Orient Express, adapted by Ken Ludwig from the classic novel by Agatha Christie.

Audition Dates

  • Sunday, July 19 at 3:00 p.m.
  • Monday, July 20 at 7:00 p.m.

Director Dustin Bond and Assistant Director Vickie Paker are excited to bring this thrilling mystery to the Playhouse stage and are hoping for a wonderful turnout at both audition sessions. Auditions are open to performers of varying experience levels, and all are encouraged to attend.

Just after midnight, a snowdrift stops the luxurious Orient Express in its tracks. By morning, an American businessman lies dead in his compartment, stabbed multiple times. With the killer still aboard the train, the renowned detective Hercule Poirot must question the train’s eclectic passengers to uncover the truth before the murderer strikes again. Filled with unforgettable characters, clever twists, and suspense from beginning to end, Murder on the Orient Express is one of the greatest mystery stories ever told.

Performance Dates

  • September 10–12
  • September 16–19

This production is proudly sponsored by Scott and Sons Trucking.

Whether you’re a seasoned performer or stepping onto the stage for the first time, the Putnam County Playhouse welcomes you to become part of this exciting production. Come audition and help bring one of the world’s most beloved mysteries to life!

Private Lives Opens This Thursday!

Season 2026 Open House is here!!!

Putnam County Playhouse Announces Annual Open House and 2026 Season Preview
Greencastle, IN — Putnam County Playhouse invites the community to its Annual Open
House on Sunday, June 7, from 2:00 to 4:00 p.m. at the Barn. This free event offers a
behind-the-scenes look at the upcoming season, along with light refreshments and an
opportunity to purchase tickets for all four productions in the 2026 season.


Guests will enjoy a special onstage preview of The Secret Garden, the Playhouse’s first
musical of the season. Cast, crew, and production staff will share a glimpse into the
rehearsal process, offering attendees an exciting sneak peek ahead of opening night.
The Secret Garden opens June 11 and runs June 11–13 and June 17–20.

The 2026 season continues with a diverse lineup of beloved productions:
 Noel Coward’s Private Lives: July 9–11 and July 15–18
 My Fair Lady: August 13–15 and August 19–22
 Agatha Christie’s Murder on the Orient Express: September 10–12 and
September 16–19

Single session tickets for all productions and Season Tickets will be available for
purchase during the Open House.
For more information about the season, visit www.putnamcountyplayhouse.com.
Join us at the Barn to celebrate the start of another exciting season—Putnam County
Playhouse looks forward to welcoming you!

Our New Season Has Begun! 🌟 

Season ticket brochures are out, and our 2026 season is officially underway! We’re thrilled to announce that our first production, The Secret Garden, has been cast and rehearsals are already in full bloom! Don’t miss a single moment of this incredible season — the best way to make sure you see it all is with season tickets

🎟 Season Ticket Deal: Individual show tickets are $15 each — four shows would total $60 — but a season ticket is just $50! That’s a $10 savings and your guaranteed seat for every performance.

📨 How to Get Yours: Download and print the attached season ticket brochure, fill it out, and mail it in with your payment. There’s also a spot on the form to contribute to our Annual Fund Drive, if you’d like to support the theatre even more.

🎭 This Season’s Lineup:  

  • June: The Secret Garden  
  • July: Private Lives  
  • August: My Fair Lady  
  • September: Murder on the Orient Express 

This summer is packed with music, laughter, mystery, and magic at the barn — and we can’t wait to see you there! Get your season tickets today and join us for a season you won’t forget! 

Putnam County Playhouse Announces 2026 Season

Putnam County Playhouse announces a four-show 2026 season featuring two musicals and two plays, including three premieres for their stage. The season highlights a mix of veteran and new directors taking on classic titles.​

2026 season lineup

  • June: The Secret Garden, directed by veteran director Shelly McFadden. This will be the first time The Secret Garden has been produced on the Putnam County Playhouse stage.​
  • July: Noel Coward’s Private Lives, directed by new director Cameron Wunderlich, also a first-time title for the theatre.​
  • August: My Fair Lady, directed by new board member and director Kathi Elliott; this musical was last produced at Putnam County Playhouse in 1996.​
  • September: Agatha Christie’s Murder on the Orient Express, directed by Dustin Bond, another new title for the Playhouse.​

Directors and past experience

  • Shelly McFadden has previously directed Putnam County Playhouse musicals including 1776, The Music Man, and The Drowsy Chaperone.​ Her last appearance on stage was as Mrs. Fezziwig in A Christmas Carol, the Musical. 
  • Cameron Wunderlich has worked as a stage manager and set designer/builder and recently appeared as the groom in Father of the Bride.​  Cameron built the set for Oklahoma, and also appeared on stage in the same show as Judd Fry.
  • Kathi Elliott has extensive vocal direction experience and served as vocal music director for A Christmas Carol, the Musical and Cinderella, The Enchanted Version in the 2025 season.​  Kath’s last appearance on stage was in Mornings at Seven.   
  • Dustin Bond directed the 2023 comedy The Play That Goes Wrong and played Curly in the 2024 production of Oklahoma!.​   He also appeared as Quasimodo in Hunchback of Notre Dame.   

Returning and new shows

The Secret Garden, Private Lives, and Murder on the Orient Express are all new productions for the Putnam County Playhouse stage. My Fair Lady returns after 30 years, having last been staged there in 1996.​

Season ticket information

Season ticket brochures are planned to be mailed in March 2026. A digital version of the brochure will also be available on the theatre’s website at https://www.putnamcountyplayhouse.com.

JOIN US ONSTAGE IN ‘JOSEPH’!!

Director Jack Randall Earles will hold two sessions of auditions for the musical ‘Joseph & The Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat’.  The first will be Sunday, June 12, at 3 p.m.  The second will be Monday, June 13, at 7 p.m.  Both will be at the Michael McClaine Rehearsal Center at the Putnam County Playhouse.

You can download an audition form HERE.

The musical will be presented August 11-13 and August 17-20. 

It is sponsored by:

Click HERE to read about our sponsor.

The leading roles include Joseph, the dreamer; the Narrator, who tells the story; Joseph’s eleven brothers and their mothers. Other roles are an Elvis-like Pharoah, Potiphar and his wife, and Jacob the “founder of the nation.” More details about the story and the characters can be found HERE.

The actresses playing the Mothers are also part of a lively ensemble that is included in most of the songs and dances.

Everyone should prepare 32 measures of a song for the audition. Morgan Asher, the musical director of the production will be on hand to provide accompaniment. The song can be from the show or another ‘Broadway’ type number. Those auditioning for the role of the Pharaoh should prepare an ‘Elvis’ type song.

After the singing, there will be a dance audition for all. Since the show is “sung-through” there are no scenes to read. Be prepared to shine in both the singing and dancing portions of the audition. And be prepared to have fun!

In addition to Asher, the production team includes Sandi Rossok as the assistant director, Kathryn Dory as the vocal director, and Cameron Wunderlich as production stage manager.

You can listen to the 1991 London Palladium Cast CD HERE.

“OLIVER!” CONTINUES AT PCPH!

Alex Gurnon as the Artful Dodger!

The musical Oliver! continues its run as the 61st season opener at Putnam County Playhouse. There are four performances left June 8-11. There are some tickets left for each performance – but most are very close to being sold out. To check on ticket availability – you must telephone the box office after 5 p.m. at 765-653-5880.

[Ticket information, reservations, exchange requests MUST be handled through the Box Office. If you leave a message on Facebook or on the website, your answer will only be delayed. We are a 100% volunteer organization, and those working on the website & Facebook pages to NOT have access to ticket information.]

With both lively and poignant songs, Oliver! is a delightful evening out for everyone. Rollicking comic characters and touching family drama combine to make every moment enjoyable.

Oliver! is directed by Caroline Good. Musical director is Amy Tharp. Kathryn Dory is the vocal director.

The title character is played by Ella Tischer. Other leading roles are played by Alex Gurnon, Grace Buehler, David Johnson, and TJ Tincher.

The show is sponsored by:

Click HERE to read about our sponsor.

The season will continue in July with the comedy-mystery Clue: Onstage.